Next Door Menu (Update 2025)
Introducing the menu at Next Door, a delightful culinary haven located in New Haven, CT, where comfort meets creativity. Known for its unique take on classic dishes, the menu showcases an array of flavorful pizzas, including the innovative Mashed Potato Pizza, which combines crispy bacon, caramelized onions, and velvety mashed potatoes on a thin crust. Vegetarian options like the Small Vinnie's Veggie and the mouthwatering Honey Brussel Bacon cater to diverse palates.
In addition to their signature pizzas, the restaurant offers delectable sides such as housemade dressings and the popular Curried Butternut Squash Soup. With a cozy atmosphere and attentive service, Next Door ensures a memorable dining experience, whether you’re enjoying a meal with family or grabbing a quick take-out. Don't forget to indulge in their delicious desserts, like chocolate mousse and lemon ricotta cookies, to round off your visit!
Soups & Stews
Vegetable Chili
hearty winter fare: pinto red beans dollop of sour cream. gluten free vegan upon request
Beef Chili
Curried Butternut Squash Soup
butternut squash, apples, coconut milk, roasted pepitas. vegan, GF
SMALL WHITE CLAM
pecorino romano, clam, & garlic (mozzarella by request)
SMALL BUFFALO CHICKEN
chicken, bell peppers, raw onion, hot sauce, gorgonzola & mozzarella
SMALL MASHED POTATO
mashed potato, caramelized onions, bacon & mozzarella
SMALL WHITE PIE
mozzarella. no tomato sauce
SMALL VINNIE'S VEGGIE
mozzarella, seasoned kale, caramelized onions, mushroom & gorgonzola vegetarian
SMALL SPICY MEATBALL
all beef meatballs, bell peppers, onion, hot cherry peppers, tomato sauce & mozzarella
SMALL CHEESE
classic tomato sauce mozzarella
SMALL FRESH TOMATO
SMALL CHICKEN BACON RANCH
SMALL FRESH MOZZARELLA
tomato sauce, fresh basil & fresh mozzarella vegetarian
SMALL EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
mozzarella, eggplant, ricotta, fresh basil vegetarian
SMALL CLAMS CASINO
light mozzarella, clam, bacon, garlic & bell peppers
SMALL HONEY BRUSSEL BACON
oven roasted brussels sprouts, spicy honey, bacon, ricotta.
SMALL NEW HAVEN PLAIN
tomato sauce, pecorino romano, evoo, oregano & fresh garlic vegetarian
SMALL RABE & SAUSAGE
broccoli rabe, longhini pork sausage, fresh garlic & mozzarella
SMALL BARBECUE CHICKEN
BBQ sauce, chicken & caramelized onions
SMALL RED PIE
tomato sauce only
Small House Pie
Sides & Extras
Side Of Honey Mustard
Side Of Ketchup
Side Of Mayo
Ceasar Dressing
Housemade Blue Cheese Dressing (4oz)
Housemade Ranch Dressing (4oz)
Side Of Dijon Mustard
Housemade Marinara Sauce (4oz)
Balsamic Dressing (4oz)
Lemon Wedges (4)
Diet Kola 12oz
Ginger Ale 12oz
Cream 12oz
Orange 12oz
Grape 12oz
Kola 12oz
Diet White Birch 12oz
Water 12oz
Seltzer 12oz
Gassosa 12oz
Lemon Lime 12oz
Cherry 12oz
White Birch 12oz
Root Beer 12oz
12Oz
Large House Pie
LARGE WHITE CLAM
pecorino romano, clam & garlic (mozzarella by request)
LARGE CHEESE
classic tomato sauce mozzarella
LARGE BARBECUE CHICKEN
BBQ sauce, chicken & caramelized onions
LARGE SPICY MEATBALL
all beef meatballs, bell peppers, onion, hot cherry peppers, tomato sauce & mozzarella
LARGE FRESH TOMATO
LARGE RED PIE
tomato sauce only
LARGE CHICKEN BACON RANCH
LARGE BUFFALO CHICKEN
chicken, bell peppers, raw onion, hot sauce, gorgonzola & mozzarella
LARGE HONEY BRUSSELS BACON
oven roasted brussels sprouts, spicy honey, bacon, ricotta.
LARGE RABE & SAUSAGE
broccoli rabe, longhini pork sausage, fresh garlic & mozzarella
LARGE FRESH MOZZARELLA
tomato sauce, fresh basil & fresh mozzarella vegetarian
LARGE VINNIE'S VEGGIE
mozzarella, seasoned kale, caramelized onions, mushroom & gorgonzola vegetarian
LARGE WHITE PIE
mozzarella. no tomato sauce.
LARGE EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
mozzarella, eggplant, ricotta, fresh basil vegetarian
LARGE MASHED POTATO
mashed potatoes, caramelized onions, bacon & mozzarella
LARGE NEW HAVEN PLAIN
tomato sauce, pecorino romano, evoo, oregano & fresh garlic
LARGE CLAMS CASINO
light mozzarella, clam, bacon, garlic & bell peppers
HALF FRESH MOZZARELLA
tomato sauce fresh basil fresh mozzarella
HALF RED PIE
tomato sauce only
HALF ESCAROLE BEAN
escarole, white beans, bacon, garlic.
HALF CHICKEN BACON RANCH
HALF HONEY BRUSSELS BACON
oven roasted brussels sprouts, spicy honey, bacon, ricotta.
HALF SPICY MEATBALL
all beef meatball bell peppers onion hot cherry peppers tomato sauce mozzarella
HALF RABE SAUSAGE
broccoli rabe longhini pork sausage fresh garlic mozzarella
HALF CHEESE
classic tomato sauce mozzarella
HALF EGGPLANT ROLLATINI
mozzarella, eggplant, ricotta, fresh basil vegetarian
HALF BUFFALO CHICKEN
chicken bell peppers raw onion hot sauce gorgonzola mozzarella
HALF FRESH TOMATO
HALF BARBECUE CHICKEN
BBQ sauce chicken caramelized onions smoked mozzarella coleslaw dressing
HALF WHITE PIE
mozzarella. no tomato sauce.
HALF NEW HAVEN PLAIN
tomato sauce pecorino romano evoo oregano fresh garlic
HALF VINNIE'S VEGGIE
mozzarella seasoned kale caramelized onions mushroom gorgonzola
HALF MASHED POTATO
caramelized onions bacon mozzarella
Half House Pie
Appetizers
ND Tacos Regular
Fish Taco
Chips Guacamole
house-made guacamole and chips.
Caprese
Fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, basil, olive oil and balsamic vinegar
Chicken Tenders
Breaded chicken strips.
ND Beef Tacos
3 tacos, all beef
ND Veggie Tacos
Cauliflower Bites
breaded cauliflower served with house-made blue cheese dressing vegetarian
Nachos
served with Pico de Gallo and sour cream
ND Shrimp Tacos
3 tacos, all shrimp
Garlic Knots
fresh baked garlic knots tossed in olive oil, fresh parsley, and pecorino romano vegan upon request.
Spicy Brussels
deep fried brussels sprouts with hot honey, parmesan sprinkle and whipped goat cheese.
French Fries
Shoestring fries with ketchup.
Fried Calamari
spicy marinara sauce no dairy, no egg
Housemade Meatballs
in marinara sauce topped with parmesan & parsley.
Chips Salsa
house-made salsa and chips.
Chicken Wings
Your choice of: traditional buffalo sauce with celery & blue cheese • spicy mango habanero • barbecue sauce.
White Birch Liter
Orange Liter
Cream Liter
Diet White Birch Liter
Cherry Liter
Root Beer Liter
Ginger Ale Liter
Gassosa Liter
Seltzer Water Liter
Kola Liter
Grape Liter
Diet Kola Liter
Liters
Handhelds
Pulled Pork Sandwich
pulled pork topped with coleslaw on a brioche bun served with fries and pickle slices.
Nacho Average Burger
All beef patty, house made chips, bacon, guacamole, cheese, white onion on a brioche roll with side of fries
Buffalo Chicken
fried chicken, buffalo sauce, lettuce, pickles, honey mustard, bacon, brioche bun
Salmon Burger
house-made salmon patty, lettuce, tomato and dill cucumber sauce served with fries.
Chicken Sandwich
house-made fried chicken, lettuce, tomato on a brioche bun served with fries.
Next Door Burger
6oz burger, lettuce, tomato on a brioche bun served with fries.
APPLE SALAD
Apples, fennel, beemster cheese, candied pecans, mixed greens (baby kale, spinach, beet tops) fennel vinaigrette
Warm Roasted Vegetable Bowl
roasted brussels, cauliflower, butternut squash & beets with kale, radicchio & pepitas. vegan gluten free
Caesar
romaine lightly coated in a rich, creamy house-made caesar dressing topped with crispy country french bread croutons, parmesan and lemon.
The Big Green Truck
romaine lettuce, english cucumbers, grape tomatoes, red onion topped with house-made balsamic vinaigrette or ranch dressing. vegetarian gluten free
Salads
Entrées
Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo
locally-made, fresh fettuccine tossed in alfredo sauce topped with sautéed chicken.
Chicken Parmigiana W/Spaghetti
chicken cutlet, layered with marinara, mozzarella and parmesan, spaghetti marinara
Prix Fix Dinner (In House Only, Fri, Sat, Sun)
Spaghetti & Meatballs
locally-made spaghetti topped with 3 of our house-made meatballs and marinara sauce.
Penne Alla Vodka
penne tossed in a vodka sauce. vegetarian
Pan Seared Salmon
everything crust, cauliflower puree, spinach, fried shallots *contains sesame
Tricolor Fettuccine
shrimp, asparagus and shitake mushrooms with lemon thyme butter
Mac & Cheese
small shells, creamy parmesan, cheddar, and asiago cheese with panko crumb topping. Try it with buffalo chicken or pulled pork!